Substitute for cornstarch in baking
Quick answer
For most baking applications, arrowroot powder is the closest 1:1 swap for cornstarch. For cookies and cakes where cornstarch tenderizes the crumb, all-purpose flour at 2 tbsp per 1 tbsp cornstarch is reliable. For pie fillings and fruit crisps, arrowroot or tapioca starch at a 1:1 ratio hold up well.
Some links below are affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, AltPantry earns from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
| Rank | Substitute | Ratio (replaces 1 cup cornstarch) | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| #1 | Arrowroot powder | 1 tbsp arrowroot powder for every 1 tbsp cornstarch | Produces a clear, glossy set in fruit pie fillings and behaves nearly identically to cornstarch in cakes and cookies. Does not hold up well if the filling is baked at high heat for a long time — it can break down and turn slimy. Best for fruit pies with moderate baking times and for tenderizing cookies or shortbread. |
| #2 | Tapioca starch | 1 tbsp tapioca starch for every 1 tbsp cornstarch | Works well in fruit pie fillings and produces a slightly stretchier, glossier gel than cornstarch. In cookies or shortbread used purely for tenderizing, it performs adequately, but the texture is marginally chewier than cornstarch produces. Widely used and tested by King Arthur Baking and America's Test Kitchen as a pie-filling thickener. |
| #3 | All-purpose flour | 2 tbsp all-purpose flour for every 1 tbsp cornstarch | The most widely available option. In cookies and shortbread, it adds gluten and produces a slightly less tender crumb than cornstarch, but the difference is modest. In pie fillings it creates a cloudier, slightly starchy-tasting result compared to cornstarch or arrowroot — acceptable in a pinch, noticeably worse in unbaked or minimally baked fruit fillings. |
| #4 | Rice flour | 1 tbsp rice flour for every 1 tbsp cornstarch | A solid option in gluten-free baking contexts where cornstarch is used as a tenderizer or to lighten texture. Produces a finer, slightly crisper crumb in shortbread and butter cookies. Less ideal for pie fillings — it thickens adequately but can leave a faintly grainy texture if not fully gelatinized. |
Why baking is different
In baking, cornstarch serves two distinct roles depending on the recipe. In cookies, shortbread, and some cakes, it dilutes gluten development and tenderizes the crumb — a textural function. In pie fillings and fruit cobblers, it acts as a starch thickener that sets during baking. A substitute that works for one role may not work equally well for the other, so knowing which function the recipe needs determines which swap is appropriate.
Common mistakes
The most common error is using the same substitute interchangeably across baking contexts. Arrowroot is excellent in fruit pie fillings but can turn gummy if baked at high heat for over an hour, making it a poor choice for deep-dish pies with long bake times. The second common mistake is substituting all-purpose flour 1:1 instead of 2:1 — using equal volumes leaves the filling under-thickened or the cookie dough with noticeably less tenderness.
Cornstarch plays two different roles in baking recipes, and that distinction matters when choosing a substitute. As a tenderizer in cookies and shortbread, it interrupts gluten formation and produces a finer, more delicate crumb — arrowroot powder and rice flour replicate this most closely at a 1:1 ratio. As a thickener in pie fillings and fruit crisps, it gelatinizes during baking to create a sliceable, stable set — tapioca starch and arrowroot both handle this well under moderate baking conditions.
All-purpose flour is the most universally available backup, but it works in a pinch rather than as a true equivalent. It clouds fruit fillings and adds more gluten than cornstarch does, which means tenderness in cookies takes a small hit. For anyone who bakes fruit pies or shortbread with any regularity, keeping arrowroot or tapioca starch in the pantry will consistently produce closer results to the original recipe.
Frequently asked questions
- Can I leave cornstarch out of a cookie recipe entirely?
- If cornstarch is listed in small amounts (1–2 tsp) in a cookie recipe, omitting it produces a slightly less tender, marginally crispier result. The cookies will still bake correctly. If a shortbread recipe calls for larger amounts (2–4 tbsp), omitting it without substituting something will noticeably toughen the texture.
- Does arrowroot work the same as cornstarch in a fruit pie filling that bakes for over an hour?
- No. Arrowroot breaks down with prolonged high heat and can become thin or slimy after extended baking. For pies that bake longer than 45–50 minutes, tapioca starch or all-purpose flour holds up more reliably.
- Can I use potato starch as a cornstarch substitute in baking?
- Potato starch works as a 1:1 swap for cornstarch in cookies and cakes where tenderizing is the goal, and it thickens pie fillings adequately. However, it has a slightly higher thickening power and can produce a gluey texture if used in excess. It's a reasonable option but less consistently tested in baking contexts than arrowroot or tapioca starch by mainstream food authorities.
← Back to all cornstarch substitutes